Stopping School Violence One Teacher’s Silent Scream Click link

Stopping School Violence One Teacher's Silent Scream

Showing posts with label LRE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LRE. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Least Restrictive Environment... Is Marley visiting?

Least Restrictive Environment is a legal term under IDEA. Far from years ago, when children with disabilities were excluded from the regular classroom "just because", IDEA affords the opportunity for more appropriate placement since 1975.

Or at least, it should (pun intended).

BUT, misinterpretation of least restrictive environment has been a real problem. The least restrictive environment has become even more restrictive...for all. 

It is not easy walking on egg shells in classrooms, but the image you get, is a reality.

I have my Master's in Special Education, but my regular classroom teaching experience and my parents taught me how to work with special needs students. Value them and do not dumb down their education. And that means for all!

The regular classroom is not always the best fit. 

Did you read my book? Read my take on inclusion?

I know that equating special needs with special rights, a talking point, is not legal. People with disabilities still have to obey the law. Mitigating circumstances such as disabilities may factor in, but breaking the law can still have serious consequences. 

Schools have to follow laws. In my opinion, the appropriate setting for placement is probably the biggest issue in non compliance.

Blind people can not legally drive. People with active seizures can not legally drive. Convicted drunk/drug users can not legally drive. Yet, in classrooms today, those disabilities all may be driving the direction of a classroom based on their individual needs when placed in a regular class of at least 25 other children.

Accomodations can be made. I am not advocating going back to pre 1975. But reality needs to be checked. What about a child with ODD?

Least restrictive environment verses best realistic and efficient placement? 

More to the point. Our schools are suffering with violent behaviors going unchecked in our regular classrooms due to IDEA.

It is a good idea, but subject to abuse.

In world infamous schools, they have gone past check points even unto death. They may shows signs indicating they are strong, but are they? 

Is murder in a classroom a badge of honor? Seems like it, right Prinicipal, DD. A lot of staff are named " Peter " too.

Is the breaking of the law a systemic issue in schools? A deep dive is not needed to connect dots.

I would say "yes" about the law breaking and did publicly state that in writing and at a microphone in 1998.  This is not a new idea.

Is a child with violent behavior really allowed to hurt someone because an IEP or 504 plan was written because of the outbursts? 

IDEA is a funding source and has guidance. It is not legal tender to get out of jail free or hurt others. Juvenile hall sometimes is the least restrictive environment.  Home instruction? I did that. Jail? Yes, I did work with students who had records. 

Have you ever been bullied into submission by IDEA. Most teachers would answer "yes".

I have personal experience but if you are an observer, one would have to be living under that rock and heads buried in the sand not to make some connections. I did speak up on behave of all my students, especially my violent student who had an IEP.  Others children had IEPs too. Those other students did not exhibit violent responses. 

How would a violent episode affect the rights of the blind student, epileptic student or a student with diabetes in class when the attack begins? They have rights to be safe. Contingency plans?

Parents and legal eagles do not work in a classroom.  Neither do child study team members. They can be part of the problem. Law makers can be too.

Special needs and school violence:

Let's look at JT from the Newport News experience in real time. Legal testimony made it clear the classroom he was in was not a good fit for him academically or behavior wise. See many posts.

What did JT do? At 6 years of age, he did a lifetime of damage to the school and possible to himself. The misinterpretation of the law cost $10 million dollars, not paid to taxpayers, but paid to the severely injured teacher he shot. That does not account for emotional damage to the people in the school and community. Do property values go up or down with violence?

Read the law, IDEA and School Safety laws. Links listed in other posts about IDEA.

Take a look at these News links. Do you think special needs is being interpreted incorrectly into special rights in some of these cases? Dig deeper if needed.

JT in Newport News and Cruz, of Parkland fame, made their schools household names to those paying attention. Parkland has a spin off community trying to take gun rights away.  Was Cruz in regular classes? He was special needs.Where are those two now? Neither died.

Ripple effects anyone?

Connect some dots. Some misinterpretations of laws get our school children, special needs or not, and staff killed. 

Bend saw a special needs classroom destroyed and children dead as well as the Special Educaton teacher killed. The shooter, it is said, had been in special education? What had been his LRE? He is dead too by a someone's gun.

Special needs student need to be protected. Violent children need protection from themselves.

Who is interpreting the cries of our children?

On a purely financial perspective:

It is all at taxpayer expense. I know some people who think that if they do not have children in school or never had children, that they should not have to pay school taxes of any kind. What if they got righteously angry?

People but not vote with their pocketbooks? School district budgets, yeah or nay?

Schools can lose funding when they break the law.

Consider these scenarios as a workshop.

Recent news at noon and 11.

Fights

https://youtu.be/6gtBMks3KGM?is=YrAl9f4XKO38eA5a

Gun

https://youtu.be/T1SZUlqX4fY?is=rKQVoCd1kVkwv1iy

Cameras

https://youtu.be/7p-k2T3LMz8?is=i3LfOBSN4NvgqLvX

Safety Incidents:

Parents demand superintendent resign:

https://youtu.be/rFPigUavUc0?is=wLkZPFWEvTdsOoyZ

Track meet death 13 and 14 year olds

https://youtu.be/N2f5QaIfG5I?is=AVzVbpofchincSPj

Cleveland. Media not allowed inside:

https://youtu.be/GTwEoy-3KMo?is=xEMUt33jaW8KRmvz

Threats:

https://www.wtae.com/article/parents-concerns-student-gun-bethlehem-center-school-district/74458084?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Email%20-%20Morning%20Headlines&utm_source=6afda15da1716327d7b5c53c682bb552&brzu=f41997e2aca7ba81ff08a8cdfa03daefa7d6d8fa616a822f4b3c135f7d9ec13d&lctg=67a78d549b5a3f007d24ec7e

What say you? Are these incidents related to IDEA and special needs not accomodated? Will some of the students become special needs? Will an IEP protect them from accountability before the fan gets clogged with bs, or after the it spreads?

If we do not judge behaviors, a judge and jury may take it out of our hands. Then, due to trauma, there maybe more students and staff with special needs in restrictive learning environments.

I can hear Marley now.

 From the Teacher's Desk with some ideas and ASKing for a friend.

Marian R. Carlino

November 18, 2026